Why Does Cat Food Smell So Bad?
Why Does Cat Food Smell So Bad?
Let’s be real: some cat food smells like it was scraped off the bottom of a fishing boat, left in the sun for a day, and then re-canned. And yet… our cats devour it like it’s Michelin-starred cuisine.
You open a pouch of Whiskas and suddenly you’re questioning all your life choices, while your cat circles like they’ve waited their whole nine lives for this moment.
But why? Why does cat food smell so bad — and why do cats love it?
Let’s get our noses into the facts (ew), because as it turns out, there’s real science, strategy, and a touch of absurdity behind the stench.
👃 Cat Food Smells Bad Because… It’s Supposed To
What smells bad to us often smells incredible to a cat.
Cats have an insanely powerful sense of smell. Where humans have about 5 million scent receptors in our noses, cats have over 200 million. That’s 40x better than us — more than some dogs. Their world is full of scents we can’t even begin to notice… or understand.
So when we open a pouch of “ocean fish in gravy,” and recoil in horror, Cookie is basically inhaling Eau de Fancy Feast with a side of delight.
What smells "fishy" or "gamey" to you smells “freshly caught and ready to pounce” to your cat.
🐾 Cats Are Obligate Carnivores — and Carnivores Love a Stink
Unlike dogs (who can eat basically anything, including your socks), cats are obligate carnivores. That means they must eat meat to survive.
Their bodies are built to crave:
Animal protein
Animal fat
Amino acids like taurine (found in muscle and organ meat)
B vitamins, especially B1 (thiamine) and B12
Now guess what smells the worst when processed and packed into cans?
👉 Organ meats and fish.
Yup. The bits we humans politely call “by-products” — liver, kidneys, hearts — are loaded with nutrients cats need. And yes, they stink. Like real bad. But to your cat, this is primal. This is nature. This is gourmet.
🧪 The Role of Processing: A Symphony of Smell
Let’s not sugarcoat it: processing animal parts to make wet food is a smelly business.
Here’s how it usually works:
The meat and by-products are cooked down (rendered) at high heat.
That slurry is blended with added nutrients, binders, and flavour enhancers.
It’s sealed into pouches or tins and sterilized under pressure.
The result? Safe, shelf-stable food that smells like something from a post-apocalyptic stew pot.
That smell gets even stronger when the pouch is opened and hits room temperature. Gravy-based cat food (like Cookie’s favourite) is especially potent because it traps aroma in the sauce until it’s released — like a perfume bomb, but for fish guts.
😽 Your Cat LOVES That Smell (Even If You Don’t)
Cats use their sense of smell to decide:
Is this safe to eat?
Is this fresh?
Is this something I’ve had before and liked?
A strong smell tells them: “Yep, meat. Real meat. Gimme.”
If it smells too mild or weirdly neutral, your cat might sniff and walk away — even if the food is perfectly good. Cookie does this sometimes with dry food — if it’s been out too long or isn’t “smelly enough,” he acts like I’m offering cardboard shavings.
🤢 Why Some Cat Foods Smell Worse Than Others
Not all cat food is created equal. Some smell… okay. Others smell like they were fished out of a radioactive swamp.
The smell factor depends on:
Type of protein (fish is by far the smelliest)
Type of fat used
How much organ meat is included
Moisture content (wet food smells more than dry)
Preservatives and enhancers
Wet foods with “real fish,” liver, or “meat by-products” tend to stink more — and yet they’re often more palatable to cats.
If your cat prefers fish flavours in gravy (like Cookie does), you're in for a particularly pungent olfactory experience.
🧼 How to Deal with the Stink (While Keeping Cookie Happy)
You're not going to stop your cat from loving stinky food. But you can manage the human side of it:
✅ 1. Store food properly
Keep wet food sealed tightly in the fridge if it’s not used immediately. Use a reusable silicone lid — they trap smell better than foil.
✅ 2. Use ceramic or stainless steel bowls
Plastic holds onto smells and can make the food seem even worse. Ceramic dishes are easier to clean and don’t trap odours.
✅ 3. Wash bowls after every meal
Don’t leave “fishy gravy” remnants lying around. The longer it sits, the worse it gets.
✅ 4. Feed in a ventilated area
A little airflow goes a long way. Feeding your cat in the kitchen with a fan or open window nearby can help clear the air.
✅ 5. Use an airtight bin for empty pouches
This is key. Don’t leave used packets in the bin all day — especially in summer. Bag them and get them out quickly or you’ll regret it.
🧴 What About Dry Food?
Dry food smells less — but that doesn’t mean your cat loves it more. Dry food lacks the moisture and volatile scent compounds that make wet food so “enticing.”
That said, some dry foods are coated in flavour enhancers (like meat broth powder or fish oil), which can still be a bit funky.
In our house, dry food is Cookie’s midnight snack, not his main course. He’ll crunch away on kibble, but when he hears a gravy pouch being opened? He appears like a ghost cat from the mist.
🐟 Final Thought: Embrace the Stink
Cat food smells gross to us because it’s full of the stuff we don’t like to eat — but our cats absolutely adore. Their powerful sense of smell is hardwired to crave strong, meaty aromas. So next time you're gagging over tuna mousse with liver sauce, remember:
That stench means the food is working
Your cat smells a banquet
And honestly… you’ve probably eaten worse things at a festival
If Cookie could write this post himself, he’d probably title it:
“Smells Like Victory.”
Comments
Post a Comment